Let's start here: Kyrie Irving is an incredible basketball
Nobody in the league has a better handle, and he probably
possesses the best layup package of all-time. He hit one of the
biggest and most memorable shots in NBA history.
Irving has earned a spot on the All-NBA team three times in his
career. He'll presumably be inducted into the Hall of Fame five
years after hanging up his Nikes.
During the 2021-22 regular season, Irving averaged 27.4 points,
5.8 assists, 4.4 rebounds, 1.4 steals and a career-high 3.4 made
three-pointers per game. At age 29, he was named an All-Star for
the seventh time.
Earlier this year, Portland Trail Blazers head coach and former
NBA Finals MVP Chauncey Billups called Irving the "the most skilled player" ever to
play the point guard position. Last month, following a 60-point
explosion from Irving in a victory over Orlando, Knicks shooting
guard Evan Fournier tweeted, "Kyrie really the most skilled player
ever." The next day, Kendrick Perkins, a former player and current
NBA analyst, concurred with Fournier, declaring, "no disrespect to Michael
Jordan… but Kyrie is the most skilled player to ever play the
So, when Irving exercises his player option this summer and
becomes an unrestricted free agent, the Nets should immediately
offer him a max contract and hope he signs it, right?
Make no mistake, as the aforementioned stats demonstrate, Irving
is deserving of a lucrative contract based on his ability. However,
the issue is that he's often been either unable or unwilling to
step onto the court and prove his worth.
Since signing a $136.5 million contract with the Nets in 2019,
Irving has appeared in just 103 of 216 (47%) regular-season games,
including only 29 of 82 this past season. During this three-season
span, he's missed games due to injuries to his left hamstring,
ankle, right shoulder, groin, right knee, quad, left hip, back and
left thigh. He also famously sat out most of this past season after
refusing to get vaccinated against COVID-19 and, in January of
2021, missed two weeks during an unauthorized leave of absence
reportedly due to trauma caused
by "the attack on the U.S. Capitol in Washington by supporters of
President Donald Trump."
Kyrie has appeared in more than 60 games just once over the last
five seasons. He's averaged fewer than 51 games played per season
in the previous seven years.
That was during the heart of his prime. Irving now finds himself
on the wrong side of 30.
Even more troublesome, in recent years, Irving's presence has
not resulted in postseason success. In the summer of 2017, when
Irving was a teammate of LeBron James in Cleveland, a team that
reached the Finals in each of the prior three seasons, Kyrie
demanded to be traded.
Here's a look at how each of Irving's seasons have ended after
Cleveland shipped him to Boston that August:
2019: Beat by the Bucks 4-1 in Round 2
2020: Injured (Raps sweep Nets in Round 1)
2021: Injured (Bucks beat Brooklyn in Round 2)
2022: Swept by the Celtics in Round 1
This summer, Irving has a decision to make. He has a player
option worth $35,328,700 for the 2022-23 campaign. If Irving
declines his option, he would be eligible to sign a new five-year deal with Brooklyn worth
up to $248 million.
After the Nets' season-ending loss to Boston in Game 4 on Monday
night, Irving bombastically declared he planned to remain in
Brooklyn for the long haul. "I don't really plan on going
anywhere," Irving said. "When I say I'm here with [Kevin Durant], I
think that it really entails us managing this franchise together
alongside Joe [Tsai] and Sean [Marks]."
(It's also worth noting that after Steve Nash was hired in
September of 2020,
Irving stated, "I don't really see us having a head coach. You
know what I mean? KD could be a head coach. I could be a head
Last month, the NBA informed franchises that the projected
salary cap for the 2022–23 season would be $122 million, according to a report from The
Athletic. Under the CBA, because Irving has 10+ years of NBA
experience, the Nets can offer him a max contract starting at 35%
of the cap and can include 8% raises each year for up to five
Here's an annual breakdown of the five-year max pact Irving is
eligible to ink:
2022-23: $42.7 million
2023-24: $46.1 million
2024-25: $49.8 million
2025-26: $53.8 million
2026-27: $58.1 million
Irving would be 35 years of age by the end of the '26-27
It's obvious why Kyrie would prefer to stay put, but would
re-signing Irving to a max deal be in Brooklyn's best interest?
This past season, owner Joe Tsai spent $266 million in salary
and luxury tax payments, which was the second-highest amount in
league history. The Nets don't have a single playoff win to show
Despite his abundant talent, Irving was a major factor in
Brooklyn's disappointing performance this year. Prior to the start
of the season, when Irving informed the front office that he was
refusing to get vaccinated, Nets management banished him from the
practice facility and team premises.
At the time, general manager Sean Marks declared, "We're not
looking for partners that are going to be half-time." Owner Joe
Tsai said the Nets needed the entire roster "pulling the same
Although the Nets 2021-22 campaign will go down
as one of the most disappointing seasons in NBA history,
Brooklyn actually got off to a fantastic start despite Irving's
non-compliance with New York City's vaccine mandate. Powered by
MVP-caliber play from Kevin Durant, the Nets posted a .724 winning
percentage over the season's first two months. On December 18th,
which was the day the Nets announced that Irving would be welcomed
back to the club, Brooklyn was 21-9 and owners of the best record
in the Eastern Conference. Following Irving's return, the Nets
struggled mightily, posting a 23-29 record (.442 winning
percentage) over the final three months of the regular season.
Late in the year, with Brooklyn in danger of slipping out of the
playoffs and the play-in tournament altogether, head coach Steve
Nash was forced to lean heavily on Durant as soon as KD returned
from his knee injury. Over the final 15 games of the regular
season, Durant logged more total minutes (588) than any player in
the NBA, averaging a whopping 39.2 minutes a night.
Durant averaged a league-high 44 minutes per game in the
In Brooklyn's embarrassing defeat to Boston in the first round,
Irving averaged just 15.3 points while shooting a putrid 37% from
the floor and a frigid 18% from downtown over the final three games
of the series. Irving was, at best, the fifth-best/most impactful
player in the series.
In some respects, this two-second clip sums up Irving's and the
Based on how the last three games, three weeks, three months and
three years have played out, do the Nets want to remain in a
long-term partnership with this man? Do they want to pony up $250
million for the privilege to do so?
Because the Nets are over the salary cap even without Irving on
the books, letting him go for nothing would be nonsensical.
However, working out a sign-and-trade would likely lead to a better
allocation of the team's assets.
Considering the current construction of the Nets roster around
Durant (and the team's lack of depth), might it make more sense for
Brooklyn to pursue a defensive-minded, pass-first point guard to
play alongside KD, Joe Harris, Ben Simmons, etc.? One which is far
more affordable than Irving?
Keep in mind that Brooklyn has nine potential free agents this
summer: Patty Mills (player option), Andre Drummond, Nic Claxton,
LaMarcus Aldridge, Blake Griffin, Kessler Edwards (team option),
David Duke Jr. and, most notably, Bruce Brown.
It's worth noting that over Games 2 and Game 3 vs. Boston, Brown
scored nearly twice as many points as Irving (49 vs. 26,
respectively) and grabbed six more rebounds. Brown is also a far
superior defender and five years younger. Not to mention he's not
nearly as much of a distraction.
Even though they are capped out, Brooklyn has a trade exception
worth $11.3 million to utilize and will be able to spend their
mid-level exception in free agency.
Tyus Jones, who again led the NBA in assist-to-turnover ratio
this season, will be a free agent this summer. Gary Payton II is
also set to hit the open market.
If Irving were open to a sign-and-trade, Brooklyn wouldn't
necessarily have to get a point guard back in such a deal. Sean
Marks and company could simply move Irving for the best packable
available, whether that be a combination of players or draft
The big "if" is whether Irving would agree to such a scenario.
Could he be convinced that his relationship with Brooklyn has run
its course and that breaking up is best for both parties? Would
Durant co-sign such a decision?
If Irving refuses a sign-and-trade, the Nets have to play
hardball in negotiations. Agreeing to commit $200+ million to a
player as injury-prone and untrustworthy as Irving would be
organizational malpractice. Brooklyn should only guarantee a
fraction of Irving's salary and should include as many incentives
as possible (such as 65+ games played per season, etc.)
Ultimately, attempting to predict future decisions from Kyrie
Irving, a man who once proclaimed the earth was flat and later
forfeited $17 million because he refused to get a shot in his arm,
is a fool's errand.
One thing is certain: It will be fascinating to see how this all