After Thursday's blockbuster trade between the Brooklyn Nets and
Philadelphia 76ers, Ben Simmons is on track to play on an NBA court
for the first time in nine months. It's been seven months since he asked
for a trade from Philadelphia and so long since he's spoken to the
media that I'm not entirely sure I remember what his voice sounds
Simmons deserves criticism for his offensive play in the
playoffs. He deserves criticism for his developmental approach. No one is devoid of
critique, especially in sports.
However, what I struggle with is the lack of nuance and
reasoning when it comes to Simmons' mental health, as many are
claiming that he's faked his issues to build a better arbitration
case. Simmons has reportedly been seeing a therapist, but refused to disclose any details
to the Sixers. Thus, Simmons' pending return to action and
eagerness to play in a new environment has set off analysts and
There's a notion that Simmons citing his mental health as the
reason he was uncomfortable practicing or playing devalues the
"actual struggles" that people go through and adds to the
stigmatization of mental health. (I'd argue off rip that claiming
someone is faking mental-health issues for money is further
stigmatizing, but you do you).
I understand some of the frustrations. On the surface, it's
murky, but this has been building for as long as I've been covering
the league, and prior to Simmons being drafted.
In case you forgot.
As early as his final year of high school at Montverde Academy,
Simmons was dubbed the "Next LeBron." Some may see that
as a compliment, and certainly it is, but I think it's so easy to
see the ridiculousness in that comparison.
Comparing and projecting a 17-year-old to perhaps the greatest
player who's ever played set Simmons up for failure long before he
made it to the league. This would be a tough position for anyone,
regardless of what you do for a living.
Let's say you're a teacher, and, man, you're damned good. You
have a gift for conveying knowledge, making learning joyful and
engaging with your students to help them grow. But, you're not
Socrates. You're not Aristotle. You set out from high school to the
education department in college, and someone saw something in you,
claiming you'd be the great educator of this generation. You're
good, but you're not the best. You've done your job, and done it
well, but all anyone wants to talk about is how great you could've
been. If only you'd been that generational talent we projected,
imagine the funding our school would be getting!
That pressure is nuts. It's one thing to say someone might be
great, but constantly comparing them to THE greatest is
I know, he gets paid an insane amount of money; he's on a
five-year, $167 million contract, and this is in part why NBA
players are paid the big bucks. Well, arguing that millions of
dollars makes someone's mental health better is lacking. With that
money and pressure comes an unreal number of eyes and voices
constantly on top of Simmons' every move. I think we often dismiss
just how hard that can be to deal with. I contemplate deleting
Twitter once a week, and I deal with a fraction of the pressure
that a professional athlete does.
There's something that's always stuck with me about who Simmons
is and how he thinks, and it's a quote from an ESPN story that ran a few years
“I could be one of those guys shooting 30% right now. But I’d
rather be one of those guys shooting 40%,” Simmon said.
Ben's shooting has always been the ire of observers, and it was
the main point of contention once again prior to this season. When
I saw that quote while reading the feature, it was eye-opening. It
sounds simplistic, but not caring is just not an easy thing to do.
Some can take failure or misses in stride, while others can really
struggle with it.
The shooting woes and reluctance have always lingered and
steadily got worse. That mental block that's always been there has
undoubtedly contributed to issues with confidence, which have been
fairly clear on court. Last year's playoff series against the
Atlanta Hawks just showcased how bad it had gotten.
Simmons was the No. 1 overall pick, the one who was supposed to
complete The Process and carry Philadelphia to a title. That
obviously didn't happen. Once Joel Embiid ascended, there were
discussions on whether they could co-exist, who was better and
which cornerstone they should build around if they failed as a
tandem, and that was cleanly eschewed last season (if not
The hype train is all well and good until it derails. If Simmons
hadn't been projected for greatness, there would've been more room
allowed for error, and he likely would've been drafted in a
different spot with different expectations, so this wouldn't be a
story. But that's not how this works.
Ben deserved criticism for his play following that series loss,
but the postgame comments from Doc Rivers after
Game 7, while not incorrect, were a slap in the face.
Some may call it "coddling" to not blast a player in the media;
I'd call it being honest about your situation and not pouring
gasoline onto napalm. Embiid had some pointed shots as well, but
they were more understandable.
Since day one in the league, Simmons has needed to be more than
he is. Part of that is duly on him, but, man, if we can't accept
our part in that as well, I don't know how else we're supposed to
go about rectifying situations like this. If we are unwilling to
acknowledge that different sets of circumstances, experiences and
difficulties can exist on planes outside our own, that's a
Selfishly, I'm glad that he got traded so we can finally just
see him on the court again. He's a really damn good player, even if
he's not quite the player that everyone wants him to be or hoped
he'd develop into.
If Simmons has lied even in the slightest about his mental
health, that's on him. It's not our job as media or fans to build
or tear down his arbitration case. It should be our obligation to
take full stock of the situation and at least try to come to an
understanding of where Ben Simmons is coming from
even if we disagree with how he's gone about it.
Looking to go to the hottest
concerts, sports, theater & family shows near you? Get 100%
guaranteed tickets to more than 125,000 live events from
TicketSmarter, the official ticket marketplace of
BasketballNews.com. Order online