The Oklahoma City Thunder responded to the pressure of a 2-1 series deficit with composure, adjustments, and a superstar performance from Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. In a must-win Game 4 of the NBA Finals, the Thunder executed a near-perfect game plan, tying the series 2-2 with a 111-104 victory over the Indiana Pacers. From SGA’s takeover to bold rotation changes and defensive wrinkles, Oklahoma City reminded everyone why they were the No. 1 seed in the West.

SGA puts on his ‘Superman’ cape again

With the season practically on the line, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander once again elevated his play. The All-NBA guard poured in 35 points, including 15 in the 4th, and dictated the pace and tempo in every quarter. It wasn’t just the numbers – it was the control. Every time Indiana threatened a run, SGA answered with a tough bucket, a timely assist, or a composed possession that steadied the Thunder.

It’s the kind of poise usually reserved for veterans with deep playoff mileage. For Gilgeous-Alexander, this postseason has been a coming-of-age story in real time. Game 4 was just the latest chapter in his superstar rise.

Thunder starts with a double-big lineup again 

After success in short stretches earlier in the series, head coach Mark Daigneault leaned fully into the double-big lineup by starting both Chet Holmgren and Isaiah Hartenstein. The move gave OKC more size at the rim, much-needed rebounding help, and physicality that wore down Indiana's frontcourt.

Hartenstein’s presence was particularly important against Indiana’s bruising interior attack. While he didn’t stuff the stat sheet, his screens, rim protection, and second-chance efforts gave the Thunder control in the paint. Holmgren, meanwhile, stretched the floor and blocked shots, proving the two can coexist when the matchup calls for it.

Alex Caruso delivers on both ends of the floor

Alex Caruso gave the Thunder a massive lift with 20 points, marking his second 20-point performance of the Finals. Known primarily for his defense and intangibles, Caruso’s offensive aggression stood out in Game 4. He hit timely threes, attacked closeouts, and punished Indiana for sagging off him.

More than just the scoring, Caruso’s energy was contagious. He drew offensive fouls, hounded Indiana’s ball-handlers, and never let the Pacers get comfortable initiating offense. In a series where every possession feels pivotal, Caruso’s two-way play has been invaluable.

OKC flips the defensive pressure on Indiana

Indiana had found success with aggressive full-court pressure earlier in the series. In Game 4, the Thunder flipped the script, applying similar tactics against the Pacers, and the result was telling.

OKC’s guards picked up full court, forcing Indiana into rushed possessions, errant passes, and late-clock decisions. It wasn't just a gimmick – it was a strategic counter that took Indiana out of rhythm. Fatigue clearly set in for Indiana’s lead guards as the game wore on, leading to turnovers and less-efficient offense.

The Thunder’s ability to adapt defensively and to use the Pacers’ own tactics against them was a quiet but key ingredient to their Game 4 win.

– – –

With the series tied and now effectively a best-of-three, all momentum has shifted back to neutral. Both teams have shown they can make adjustments, and both have stars capable of swinging games. But with Gilgeous-Alexander continuing his heroic run and Daigneault showing tactical flexibility, Oklahoma City heads into Game 5 with a renewed sense of belief—and a real shot to seize control of the Finals.