Over the past few years, nobody has been more vocal about Kyrie Irving than Stephen A. Smith.
“Kyrie Irving is saying basketball is not a priority to me…..Kyrie Irving until you want to play, you should retire," Smith said on ESPN's First Take on Jan. 13, 2021. "Forfeit every penny you make, retire and go do what you wanna do in regard to these issues that are clearly most important to you.”
“We are witnessing one of the most delusional athletes in American history," Smith doubled down on April 29. "He’s lost…What it comes down to Kyrie is you don’t want to show up to work. You wanna do what you wanna do, when you wanna do it, how you wanna do it, and then you have your hand out for somebody else’s money."
These takes — which have been repeatedly expressed by Stephen A. and those of his ilk for the past few years — have sparked a nationwide demonization of Kyrie Irving.
To debate this and the ongoing rift between the NBA players and the media, I sat down with two media giants that I have a great deal of respect for in The Athletic's David Aldridge and Marc Spears of ESPN's Andscape. We discussed the contrast between the old media and new media, what the role of the media should be and what real effects talking heads like Stephen A., Skip Bayless, Nick Wright and those of their ilk have on the entire basketball world.
Although we disagreed for the majority of the discussion, this was a healthy debate with different perspectives presented — the way discussions/debates should be.
(Editor's Note: Watch the entire exchange below on BasketballNews' YouTube channel and subscribe to Etan's podcast "The Rematch.")
Etan Thomas: I’ll agree with both of you that the majority of the media, whatever bucket you want to include everyone in, does not conduct themselves like Stephen A. Smith, or Skip Bayless or Nick Wright or those of that ilk. But they are the loudest voices. And those are the voices that you hear everyday. And those loud voices drive not only the masses of sports fans, but it also impacts the way that journalists write their articles.
Marc Spears: "Let me stop you right quick. You mentioned (Fox News) earlier — they present their misinformation as facts, whereas [Nick] Wright and [Stephen A.] Smith, they’re just speaking on sports and giving their opinion."
Etan: But they are presenting their opinions as though they are facts. Honestly, Stephen A. Smith has the same power over the masses that Tucker Carlson has over the Right. They’ll say all the time that Tucker Carlson is not a real journalist, he’s not a real member of the media, but he still has the same media power over the minds of the masses
Spears: "Stephen A. doesn’t conjur racism."
Etan: I’m not talking about the topic, I’m talking about the level of power and influence.
David Aldridge: "Etan for the sake of the discussion, I’ll accept your comparison. If the argument is these people are on TV everyday (and) therefore, they have a lot of power, therefore, their opinions carry weight. But I will come back to again: With who? (Laughing) Who do they carry all of this weight with?"
Etan: With the entire sports world.
Aldridge: "But Etan, I would have to disagree with you because it’s not the entire sports world. Because the entire sports world would include team owners, team general managers, head coaches, players. And nobody has gotten more bad criticism as of late than Kyrie. Let’s use Kyrie Irving as an example.
"Kyrie just opted in for $37 million, and guess what? When he’s a free agent next year, somebody else is going to give him a big contract. Might be Brooklyn, might not be. But somebody is going to give Kyrie some more paper to play."
Etan: You don’t think the narrative that has been repeated by those like Stephen A. Smith and those of that ilk has hurt the entire image of Kyrie? Going from this past year, let’s examine why he was sitting out. During the pandemic and he didn’t want to take the vaccine. He was uncomfortable with the vaccine, which a large portion of the country was as well. I had a different conclusion than he had, but I respect his conclusion. Everybody was ok with it until... he started missing games. Then it was like, 'Wait a minute now, we can’t have this.' Then, you had Stephen A Smith saying, 'Oh he doesn’t want to play, oh he doesn’t respect the game,' and that started creating a narrative where the entire pendulum started to shift completely on Kyrie.
Aldridge: "Do you believe Etan, if I say I can agree with you on Stephen A. Smith voicing his opinion, do you think nobody on the Brooklyn Nets had the same opinion? Do you think the Brooklyn Nets were saying to themselves, 'Yeah, we would love for Kyrie to play, but we respect his position on the vaccine?'"
Etan: But nobody on the Brooklyn Nets was carrying the narrative publicly that he was abandoning his team. So once you have a Stephen A. Smith, who says that repeatedly, then you have journalists who start repeating what Stephen A Smith said in their articles. Then, you have an entire narrative that permeates throughout the entire country.
Aldridge: "Etan, I will humbly submit to you that there were a lot of people within the Brooklyn organization who had the exact same position."
Etan: I’m not talking about that, I’m saying they weren’t saying it publicly.
Aldridge: "Their focus was they needed Kyrie to win. They were trying to win championships."
Etan: Of course.
Kyrie Irving is 100% correct and spot on with this and the media members who fall into this category will be quick to take offense because they know it applies directly to them https://t.co/ItgLF5N0eg— Etan Thomas (@etanthomas36) April 29, 2022
Aldridge: "Okay, so that’s my point. They didn’t want to say it publicly, but that didn’t mean they didn’t have the opinion. The inference is that only journalists had this opinion (and that) not a lot of people had this opinion. (The talking heads) said it (publicly), yes, but that doesn’t mean that other people didn’t have the same opinion."
Spears: "A lot of people had the same opinion, I just think Stephen A. was just probably loudest with it."
Aldridge: "So if lots of people had the same opinion..."
Etan: I think you’re still discounting the power of the pen, whether it’s the power of the pen or the microphone that Stephen A. Smith and those of that ilk have. There is power in it, so when you repeat something over and over again, there is power in it.
Aldridge: "Okay there’s power in it; I’m saying the impact of the power I believe is far less. And look, we all love sports — we all make our living in sports, all of us love writing, talking, thinking about sports, we’re all fans of sports. But, it’s not the same... I don’t believe the power of say, the political media, the political press to shape agendas, whereas a legacy media like the New York Times has an outsized influence on the way the rest of the political press covers things, because people still read the New York Times everyday.
"That’s way different than, I would suggest, any talking head on one of the sports debate shows. Do they have influence? Yes. Do they have some ephemeral type of power and influence over a certain segment of the population? I would agree. I would again say, 'What is the impact of that power on a player?' I would say, 'Does it help shape perception of a player?' Yes it does. I would agree with you. It does help shape perception of a player."
Etan: But you don’t think the perception of a player has any impact on a GM, or a President or a team? That’s what you’re telling me?
Aldridge: "I would ask you, if you were talking about who has the worst reputation in pro basketball right now — I don’t have an answer, I’m asking you. Based on the 'media’s' shaping of their perception, who has the worst reputation right now? Kyrie? Maybe it’s Kyrie. Let’s say for the sake of the discussion it’s Kyrie Irving, because of people have killing him because of the vaccine and a lot of other things.
"Let’s just say Kyrie has the worst reputation right now in the NBA. He’s going to be a free agent next year. I defy you to tell me that he’s not going to get paid next year, regardless of this perception of him. If you’re gonna tell me that Kyrie is going to have to take the minimum next year, I would tell you that you are incorrect. Kyrie will not be playing for the minimum."