I’ve had the privilege of being around some great players,
including some guys from the NBA’s 75th anniversary team.
In Boston, I was teammates with Kevin Garnett, Paul Pierce and
Ray Allen. In Miami, I had Shaquille O’Neal and Dwyane Wade showing
me how to become a champion. I played with Chris Paul in New
Orleans, coached LeBron James and Kyrie Irving in Cleveland, and
was fortunate to have other guys like Antonio McDyess, Nick Van
Exel and Steve Francis show me what success at the NBA level looked
I’ve been around the game for a long time and, even though the
game has changed, one of the constants has been players of the
older generation telling the younger players they couldn’t cut it
“back in the day.”
Charles Oakley became the latest to make those kinds of comments
earlier this week when Oak said that Giannis Antetokounmpo wouldn’t
even be a starter if he played back in the 1980s or 1990s.
I wouldn’t necessarily say that I agree with Oak, but to be
honest with you, I understand why he would feel that way. To go
even further, I understand why most of the older players feel that
way about the younger players in general.
There’s always going to be people on either side of the
argument, but one thing we can all agree on is the fact that the
game is way different now than it was 30 years ago.
On a personal level, I feel like I’m kind of caught between the
two generations. I grew up watching Scottie Pippen and people
compared me to him. I was drafted in 1999, but I was shown the
ropes by guys like McDyess and Nick the Quick, who more so came up
in those times. At the same time, I played 12 years and I think I
saw that transition happen right before my eyes. Things just slowly
Truth be told, I think there’s a lack of respect on both
Older players like Oakley look at younger players and, for the
most part, don’t really think they’re tough. Today, the league is
more about protecting offensive players, protecting shooters and
encouraging high-scoring games than it was back in the 1990s. Go
back and watch some tape and you’ll see. If Michael Jordan played
by today’s rules, for example, he could probably average 50.
Meanwhile, if Steph Curry went back to the 1980s and had to play
against Isiah Thomas and the Detroit Bad Boys, and if he was seeing
that kind of competition every night, if he wasn’t encouraged to
shoot 15 three-pointers every game… Would he have become the same
Maybe he still would have. I’m just saying, that’s where the
arguments come from. Older players just think that the league has
become soft, and they don’t respect how players exaggerate contact
and go out of their way to draw fouls the way it’s become so common
in today’s game.
On the other hand, one of the things I’ve heard a lot from
younger players and people who think guys like Giannis and Steph
could go back and dominate is the “lack of skill” that some of the
older players had, and I don’t think that’s true at all.
In recent times, we began to equate a guys’ skill with his
flash. Guys like Dr. J, George Gervin and Dominique Wilkins got
accolades and attention, partially because of the things they could
do, but so many other guys — guys like Charles Oakley — simply
played the game in a no-nonsense type of way.
Guys like Oakley focused on fundamentals and on being able to
perform their jobs well on the court, and I think the current
generation of players and fans — when they look back at those guys
— try to act like they weren’t “good” because they weren’t doing
flashy dunks or crossing people over.
Even worse, a lot of the time we try to act like a lot of what
we see today isn’t a result of evolution. Guys like Giannis and
Steph were either watching the previous generation or were taught
by the guys who came before them. Would we have gotten Giannis if
we never had Kevin Durant? Would we have had KD if we never had
Dirk? Would we have had Dirk if we never had someone like George
Gervin or Ralph Sampson?
I grew up being taught to respect my elders, and I think we
should remember to do that.
At the same time, the older generation needs to understand that
the game has changed and is just played differently. There’s no
reason to think that someone like Steph wouldn’t have been able to
get buckets against someone like Isiah or Derek Harper or whoever.
He would’ve had to adjust and find ways to be effective, just like
he did in his earlier days when he was squaring off against other
The whole thing actually got me thinking: if I had a time
machine and could make an imaginary pickup game with today’s
players against players from the 1980s and 1990s, which matchups
would I like to see?
Ultimately, I think the winning team would be decided by which
set of rules the imaginary pickup game was played under. If you
were playing with today’s rules, Isiah would probably get called
for three hand-checking fouls on Steph in the first five minutes of
If we were playing in the 1990s, though, Anthony Davis would
probably get caught with an elbow from Karl Malone and need some
time to recover. Worse for AD? There probably wouldn’t even be a
foul called on the play.
If I could have it my way, I’d take one player from each
position and two wildcards.
At point guard, as I’ve already hinted at, I’d like to see Chris
Paul vs. Isiah. Both are all-time great point guards and both guys
are tough competitors.
At shooting guard, I’d take Reggie Miller and James Harden. Two
of the greatest shooters ever, and also two of the best actors,
haha. I’d be interested in seeing how well Reggie would be able to
keep up with and stay in front of James and also whether James
could be effective without necessarily getting a bunch of free
I’d obviously have to put MJ and LeBron in there. Even though MJ
is a shooting guard, I’d have to cross-match them. It’d be great to
see whether MJ could score on LeBron at will the way he pretty much
did against everyone else.
Karl Malone and Anthony Davis is an interesting one. Malone was
as tough as they come, and AD doesn’t really have that type of
reputation. That said, AD is a superior offensive player and one
who can score from almost anywhere. I’d definitely want to see how
The Brow managed to hold his own against The Mailman.
At center, I’d take Shaq and Joel Embiid to go at it. Embiid
reminds me of Shaq a little just because he’s so dominant, but so
agile. Because Shaq was so strong, people really don’t give him the
credit he deserves for being a great defender (when he tried) and
for being able to move without the ball and see his teammates.
For my two wildcards, so to speak, I’d want to cross-match Kevin
Durant and Larry Bird and Steph Curry and Mahmoud Abdul-Rauf.
Durant and Curry are probably the superior talents, but Bird never
saw a challenge he couldn’t meet. He also never saw a player quite
like KD, though, so it’d be interesting. Curry would obviously have
to be in this matchup, and the reason I’d pick Abdul-Rauf is mainly
because I think he’s someone who isn’t talked about enough. He
definitely wasn’t on the level of Steph, but he was a great scorer
and someone who could control a game. And even if Steph was
lighting him up, he wouldn’t be asking for any double-team. If
Abdul-Rauf played in this generation, I think his entire career
would have been different.
So that would be my ultimate pickup game:
Isiah Thomas, Reggie Miller, Michael Jordan, Karl Malone,
Shaquille O’Neal, Larry Bird and Mahmoud Abdul-Rauf vs. Chris Paul,
James Harden, LeBron James, Anthony Davis, Joel Embiid, Kevin
Durant and Steph Curry.
Just writing out those names for the new-school team makes me
wonder how on earth the old-school team would be able to stop them
from scoring… But I think Isiah, MJ, Malone and Shaq would band
together to find a way… Or at least go down swinging. Probably
The game has definitely changed. Some people may like the
changes, some may not. Either way, one thing is for sure: no matter
what era you’re from, it’s not easy to succeed in the NBA. We all
deserve each other’s respect, and whether or not you agree with Oak
and his assessment of Giannis, we can’t take away the fact that the
Greek Freak is the reigning Finals MVP.
Whether in 1980 or 2021, that trophy has always carried the same
weight. That’s something I’d challenge my old-schoolers to always
keep in mind.