NBAPlay Hoops Rank

“Might Be a Steph Curry-Monta Ellis Situation”: Gilbert Arenas Warns NBA Team of Potential Dilemma Involving Roty Contender

Nov 16, 2026, 7:26 PM CUT

Imago

More than a decade ago, the Golden State Warriors saw the rise of a new dynasty, which sent Monta Ellis to the Milwaukee Bucks, crowned Stephen Curry as the new cornerstone and brought in multiple titles. While history follows the trend of repeating itself, former NBA star Gilbert Arenas believed that the Utah Jazz might face something similar this time.

“This might be a Steph, Monta Ellis situation where you're saying Keyonte George is here,” he said during a recent episode of The Gilbert Arenas Show. “We can see (Darryn) Peterson here, but his ceiling's here because he's 6'6", athletic ... and we're just gonna have to move (Keyonte) so Peterson can turn into what he's going to turn into.”

After being the face of the Golden State for approximately seven years, Ellis’ place at the franchise was visibly shaken up during rookie Curry’s arrival in 2009. Although both of them had fundamentally different impacts, the similarity between these two ball-dominant players forced the Warriors to choose between the high-volume scorer Ellis and gravitational, natural playmaker Curry.

Imago

Now, the Jazz are probably going to stand at the crossroads between star rookie Peterson and four-season old guard George sooner or later. Although George is averaging 20.3 points, 6.6 assists, and 4.5 rebounds this season and has kept up a consistently good performance, Arenas noted that Peterson will have more room to evolve and grow in George’s absence, given his higher athleticism.

However, making such decisions has never been easy. When Ellis left the Warriors in the 2011-12 season, he averaged 21.9 points, 6.0 assists, and 3.4 rebounds. It wasn’t a move the fans were happy with, making the Warriors the subject of heavy backlash and criticism until Curry proved himself. Similarly, George made the NBA All-Rookie Second Team in the 2023-24 season, and Peterson has been averaging 17.1 points, 4.3 rebounds, and 3.8 assists this season, playing as a true ROTY contender. So, having to choose between these two guards will, by no means, be easy for the Jazz.

“And it's hard to see right now because one was averaging 24 (points) last year,” Arenas added. “You got to watch it and see who has the bigger upside. Is Keyonte a superstar, or is he just a great All-Star guy that can make it if our team is winning? Or is he an individual; no matter what the team's success is, he is making the All-Star Game. Or is that Peterson in two years?”

The key to finding all these answers is time, playing more games and observing these two closely. But the Jazz will be in for a big decision when the time comes, nonetheless. And it’ll be interesting to see how it plays out.

Related articles
Written by
BasketballNews

Stay up to date with the latest NBA news, scores, stats, analysis, and stories from around basketball.

Sportainment Inc. @2026 | All rights reserved