NBA Legend Calls LeBron James Underachiever as Shocking Russell Westbrook Comparison Emerges
Imago
April 30, 2025, Los Angeles, California, USA: LeBron James 23 of the Los Angeles Lakers during a press conference, PK, Pressekonferenz after loosing Round One Game Five of the 2025 NBA, Basketball Herren, USA Playoffs to the Minnesota Timberwolves on Wednesday April 30, 2025 at Crypto.com Arena in Los Angeles, California. Lakers loses to Timberwolves, 96-103. JAVIER ROJAS PI Los Angeles USA - ZUMAp124 20250430_zaa_p124_027 Copyright: xJavierxRojasx IMAGO / ZUMA Press Wire
Olden Polynice made headlines with a bold claim that LeBron James' move to the 76ers would reshape how people remember his legacy. Now, the former NBA center is back with another take.
He argued that, despite four championships, four MVPs and the NBA's all-time scoring record, LeBron James actually underachieved. Speaking on SiriusXM NBA Radio alongside Justin Termine and Eddie Johnson, Polynice made clear his critique wasn't based on disrespect.
"I love LeBron, I really do. I think he's one of the greatest ever, ever," Polynice said. "What he's doing right now, we've never seen before, and I won't even get into the off-court. He is by himself over there."
"At the same time, I can still be critical of him on some things," Polynice continued. "One in particular, I thought LeBron should have averaged a triple-double way before Russell Westbrook. That's my opinion, because he's big, strong, and everything else. He's the most talented guy that we've seen in a long time. But yet, Russell Westbrook averaged a triple-double, and LeBron didn't."
Westbrook owns the NBA's all-time triple-double record and posted four separate triple-double seasons between 2016-17 and 2020-21. A level James, for all his size, strength and passing ability, never matched across 22 seasons.
It's that specific gap, not James' scoring, longevity or ring count, that pushed Polynice to a conclusion he admitted sounded absurd coming out of his own mouth.
Polynice played for five franchises across his career. He crossed paths with James for just one season, in 2003-04, and never played for the team that drafted him.
Analysts have also pushed back on the argument itself. They noted that a season-long triple-double depends heavily on role, pace, and opportunity. Factors that shift for a player who spent much of his prime as his team's primary scorer rather than a pass-first player.
Still, Polynice hasn't backed off his LeBron commentary this offseason. He already suggested weeks earlier that James' decision to join the 76ers would reshape his legacy one way or another. Whether fans agree with the take or not, the underachiever label is unlikely to stick to a résumé as decorated as James'.
But Polynice has no plans to stop measuring him against a bar nobody else in NBA history has ever cleared.
Ubong Archibong is an NBA writer at BasketballNews, bringing over two years of experience in basketball coverage. Having previously worked with BasketballNews, Sportskeeda and FirstSportz, he has developed a strong foundation in delivering timely and engaging content around the league. His coverage focuses on game analysis, player performances, and evolving narratives across the National Basketball Association. Blending statistical insight with storytelling, Ubong aims to go beyond the immediate headline by placing performances and moments within a broader context, helping readers better understand the dynamics shaping the game. His work prioritizes clarity, accessibility, and a fan-first approach that connects audiences to both the action and the personalities behind it. Before joining BasketballNews, Ubong covered the NBA and WNBA across multiple platforms, building experience in fast-paced reporting and deadline-driven publishing. His background in content writing has strengthened his ability to balance speed with accuracy, ensuring consistent and reliable coverage for a global audience.
Know moreKoushik Biswas